Hay Beach holiday homes
We found 13 holiday rentals — enter your dates for availability
Discover a selection of 11 homes and other holiday rentals in Hay Beach that are perfect for your trip. Holiday homes provide the best amenities for your family, friends or furry companion, such as Wi-Fi and a hot tub. At the end of the day, you'll find a property to rent that has what everyone needs, including accessible or non-smoking choices.
Find spaces that suit your style
House
Condo/Apartment
Find the best place to stay - Hay Beach

Shelter Island Spacious Getaway with Cozy Fireplace
Sleeps 6 · 3 bedrooms · 2 bathrooms
8.0 out of 10
very good
(1 review)
- Peace of mindOur Book with Confidence guarantee gives you 24/7 support
- More quality timeFrom booking to staying, the whole process is simple and enjoyable
- All the privacy of homeEnjoy full kitchens, laundry, pools, gardens and more
- More for lessMore space, more privacy, more amenities — more value
Frequently asked questions
More holiday ideas
- North Haven Holiday Rentals
- Amagansett Beach Holiday Rentals
- Sag Harbor Marine Park Holiday Rentals
- Sag Harbor Holiday Rentals
- Springs Holiday Rentals
- Village of East Hampton Holiday Rentals
- Town of East Hampton Holiday Rentals
- Sunset Beach Holiday Rentals
- East Hampton North Holiday Rentals
- East Hampton Holiday Rentals
- Southold Holiday Rentals
- Mattituck Holiday Rentals
- North Sea Holiday Rentals
- Truman's Beach Holiday Rentals
- Southampton Cultural Center Holiday Rentals
- Clearwater Beach Holiday Rentals
- Foster Memorial Town Beach Holiday Rentals
- Mecox Bay Holiday Rentals
- Shelter Island Holiday Rentals
- Water Mill Holiday Rentals
- Hamptons Holiday Rentals
- Silver Beach Holiday Rentals
- Amagansett Dunes Holiday Rentals
- Orient Point Holiday Rentals
- Shelter Island Heights Holiday Rentals
- Southampton Holiday Rentals
- Bridgehampton Holiday Rentals
- Peconic Holiday Rentals
- Greenport Holiday Rentals
- Southampton Arts Center Holiday Rentals
- Bed and breakfasts in Long Island





