Holiday rentals near Pickleville Playhouse
We found 791 holiday rentals — enter your dates for availability
If you'd like to stay close to Pickleville Playhouse, scroll through and discover private holiday rentals to find the perfect one for your trip. Whether you're staying in a holiday rental with friends, family or just with your pet, you'll find the best amenities for hanging out with the people that matter most, which might include parking and a fireplace. You'll be able to choose a property to rent to meet everyone's needs, including places that are non-smoking or accessible.
Holiday rentals with weekly discounts - Pickleville Playhouse
Showing deals for:19 Sept - 26 Sept
Image gallery for Private beach, pools/hot tub, winter sports, sleeps 20
1010 out of 10 rating
Exceptional
(24 reviews)
Private beach, pools/hot tub, winter sports, sleeps 20
Fish Haven, ID
8% off
Price is NZ$7,421
NZ$7,421
NZ$1,060 per night
includes taxes & fees
Image gallery for Blue View Bear Lake--5 bedroom 3.5 bath log cabin, incredible views! Sleeps 18!
1010 out of 10 rating
Exceptional
(68 reviews)
Blue View Bear Lake--5 bedroom 3.5 bath log cabin, incredible views! Sleeps 18!
Garden City, UT
6% off
Price is NZ$7,929
NZ$7,929
NZ$1,133 per night
includes taxes & fees
Image gallery for Built 2023!180-degree lake views, huge deck, 6+ acres, fiber, ping pong!
1010 out of 10 rating
Exceptional
(11 reviews)
Built 2023!180-degree lake views, huge deck, 6+ acres, fiber, ping pong!
Fish Haven, ID
8% off
Price is NZ$7,858
NZ$7,858
NZ$1,123 per night
includes taxes & fees
Image gallery for Kozy Retreat @ Bear Lake - 6 KING Beds, Bunk Room, Lake View, Deck w/ Grill
1010 out of 10 rating
Exceptional
(9 reviews)
Kozy Retreat @ Bear Lake - 6 KING Beds, Bunk Room, Lake View, Deck w/ Grill
Garden City, UT
7% off
Price is NZ$8,827
NZ$8,827
NZ$1,261 per night
includes taxes & fees
Image gallery for 7 King Beds! Private Hot Tub, Pickleball Court, SUP’s, Ping Pong and Air Hockey
1010 out of 10 rating
Exceptional
(26 reviews)
7 King Beds! Private Hot Tub, Pickleball Court, SUP’s, Ping Pong and Air Hockey
Garden City, UT
7% off
Price is NZ$11,973
NZ$11,973
NZ$1,710 per night
includes taxes & fees
Image gallery for The Westlake Escape - Amazing Views, Large Entertaining Yard, and Hot Tub
1010 out of 10 rating
Exceptional
(96 reviews)
The Westlake Escape - Amazing Views, Large Entertaining Yard, and Hot Tub
Garden City, UT
8% off
Price is NZ$13,187
NZ$13,187
NZ$1,884 per night
includes taxes & fees
Image gallery for The DogWoods is a dog-friendly house 2 min walk to beach access - 6 bedrooms
1010 out of 10 rating
Exceptional
(12 reviews)
The DogWoods is a dog-friendly house 2 min walk to beach access - 6 bedrooms
Garden City, UT
8% off
Price is NZ$9,690
NZ$9,690
NZ$1,384 per night
includes taxes & fees
Image gallery for Family-friendly Retreat w/ Hot Tub, Games & Views!
9.89.8 out of 10 rating
Exceptional
(8 reviews)
Family-friendly Retreat w/ Hot Tub, Games & Views!
Garden City, UT
8% off
Price is NZ$12,648
NZ$12,648
NZ$1,807 per night
includes taxes & fees
Image gallery for A view from the top of the Reserve.
1010 out of 10 rating
Exceptional
(13 reviews)
A view from the top of the Reserve.
Fish Haven, ID
8% off
Price is NZ$29,985
NZ$29,985
NZ$4,284 per night
includes taxes & fees
Image gallery for 3 minutes from State Marina Private Hot Tub! Playground!
9.69.6 out of 10 rating
Exceptional
(111 reviews)
3 minutes from State Marina Private Hot Tub! Playground!
Garden City, UT
7% off
Price is NZ$5,103
NZ$5,103
NZ$729 per night
includes taxes & fees
Image gallery for May, June and July Specials check the rates they will never be lower!
9.89.8 out of 10 rating
Exceptional
(83 reviews)
May, June and July Specials check the rates they will never be lower!
Garden City, UT
11% off
Price is NZ$13,620
NZ$13,620
NZ$1,946 per night
includes taxes & fees
Image gallery for 10Bedroom 6 bath Lakeview Retreat with Year-Round Hot Tub & Unique Entertainment
1010 out of 10 rating
Exceptional
(55 reviews)
10Bedroom 6 bath Lakeview Retreat with Year-Round Hot Tub & Unique Entertainment
Garden City, UT
7% off
Price is NZ$13,177
NZ$13,177
NZ$1,882 per night
includes taxes & fees
Image gallery for Amazing views with a big yard, pickleball court, and lots of parking!
1010 out of 10 rating
Exceptional
(48 reviews)
Amazing views with a big yard, pickleball court, and lots of parking!
Garden City, UT
8% off
Price is NZ$10,992
NZ$10,992
NZ$1,570 per night
includes taxes & fees
Image gallery for Amazing Beachfront Lodge at Bear Lake w/ theater
8.08.0 out of 10 rating
Very good
(6 reviews)
Amazing Beachfront Lodge at Bear Lake w/ theater
Fish Haven, ID
8% off
Price is NZ$23,091
NZ$23,091
NZ$3,299 per night
includes taxes & fees
Image gallery for Luxurious farmhouse industrial design. Private HotTub, relax with gorgeous views
9.89.8 out of 10 rating
Exceptional
(18 reviews)
Luxurious farmhouse industrial design. Private HotTub, relax with gorgeous views
Garden City, UT
7% off
Price is NZ$8,691
NZ$8,691
NZ$1,242 per night
includes taxes & fees
Image gallery for Hot Tub, Game Room, Only 2 Blocks from the Lake!
9.89.8 out of 10 rating
Exceptional
(20 reviews)
Hot Tub, Game Room, Only 2 Blocks from the Lake!
Garden City, UT
11% off
Price is NZ$6,960
NZ$6,960
NZ$994 per night
includes taxes & fees
Image gallery for NEW Bear Lake home minutes from Garden City, GORGEOUS views, and Private Hot Tub
1010 out of 10 rating
Exceptional
(5 reviews)
NEW Bear Lake home minutes from Garden City, GORGEOUS views, and Private Hot Tub
Garden City, UT
7% off
Price is NZ$5,839
NZ$5,839
NZ$834 per night
includes taxes & fees
Image gallery for Bear Lake- Luxury Home, Beach Access, Pool Access, Private Community - Sleeps 30
9.89.8 out of 10 rating
Exceptional
(98 reviews)
Bear Lake- Luxury Home, Beach Access, Pool Access, Private Community - Sleeps 30
Fish Haven, ID
8% off
Price is NZ$7,817
NZ$7,817
NZ$1,117 per night
includes taxes & fees
Image gallery for 3 open spots in July 2025! Indoor play area. Great space for large groups!
1010 out of 10 rating
Exceptional
(177 reviews)
3 open spots in July 2025! Indoor play area. Great space for large groups!
Garden City, UT
8% off
Price is NZ$11,156
NZ$11,156
NZ$1,594 per night
includes taxes & fees
Image gallery for Prime location!! 3 bedroom Gorgeous Bear Lake view
1010 out of 10 rating
Exceptional
(16 reviews)
Prime location!! 3 bedroom Gorgeous Bear Lake view
Garden City, UT
8% off
Price is NZ$5,396
NZ$5,396
NZ$771 per night
includes taxes & fees
Image gallery for 16 Bedroom stream-side Lodge on 3 acres, 3-night min Summer & Holidays-sleeps 60
9.49.4 out of 10 rating
Exceptional
(15 reviews)
16 Bedroom stream-side Lodge on 3 acres, 3-night min Summer & Holidays-sleeps 60
Fish Haven, ID
8% off
Price is NZ$14,579
NZ$14,579
NZ$2,083 per night
includes taxes & fees
Image gallery for Summer mountain getaway + private hot tub!
9.69.6 out of 10 rating
Exceptional
(9 reviews)
Summer mountain getaway + private hot tub!
Garden City, UT
8% off
Price is NZ$4,228
NZ$4,228
NZ$604 per night
includes taxes & fees
Image gallery for FREE NIGHT-Large FARMHOUSE--SLEEPS 45--Book 3 get 1 Free -- Off season dates
9.89.8 out of 10 rating
Exceptional
(94 reviews)
FREE NIGHT-Large FARMHOUSE--SLEEPS 45--Book 3 get 1 Free -- Off season dates
Garden City, UT
8% off
Price is NZ$14,022
NZ$14,022
NZ$2,003 per night
includes taxes & fees
Image gallery for Beautiful Townhouse Retreat walking distance to shakes!
1010 out of 10 rating
Exceptional
(14 reviews)
Beautiful Townhouse Retreat walking distance to shakes!
Garden City, UT
7% off
Price is NZ$2,948
NZ$2,948
NZ$421 per night
includes taxes & fees
Find spaces that suit your style
House
Condo/Apartment
Cabin
Cottage
Villa
Chalet
Find the best place to stay - Pickleville Playhouse
Come enjoy a centrally located escape at Bear Lake. Hot Tub and Game Room!
Sleeps 12 · 6 bedrooms · 3 bathrooms
1010 out of 10
Exceptionalexceptional
1 review(1 review)
Blue Lake Townhouse ~ Close to Marina & Mike’s Market
Sleeps 12 · 3 bedrooms · 3 bathrooms
Walk to Marina & Lake: Spacious Garden City Gem!
Sleeps 14 · 3 bedrooms · 3 bathrooms
Comfortable lake-view getaway with central AC, WiFi, pool & hot tub
Sleeps 8 · 2 bedrooms · 2 bathrooms
9.29.2 out of 10
Wonderfulwonderful
37 reviews(37 reviews)
Sapphire 66 | Porch & Views
Sleeps 10 · 3 bedrooms · 2 bathrooms
Nature Calls- New home, hot tub & Ideal Beach Pass
Sleeps 26 · 6 bedrooms · 3 bathrooms
1010 out of 10
Exceptionalexceptional
6 reviews(6 reviews)
Peace of mindOur Book with Confidence guarantee gives you 24/7 support
More quality timeFrom booking to staying, the whole process is simple and enjoyable
All the privacy of homeEnjoy full kitchens, laundry, pools, gardens and more
More for lessMore space, more privacy, more amenities — more value