Shelter Island lake rentals

You'll find a wonderful selection of lakefront holiday homes in and near Shelter Island. If you'd like a break close to the water, these enticing options should be at the top of your list:

• Enjoy picture-perfect lake views from "Waterfront Cottage Perfection". With amenities including spa and beauty services and a nearby laundromat to make you feel at home, your main priority here is enjoying yourself.
• Ready access to the water and the sweet comforts of home make "Montauk House With Lake View" hard to top. This sought-after lakeside retreat comes with games, a nearby bay and more.

A pool is often a must-have when deciding where to stay, particularly if you're travelling with kids. Want to be by the water too? Go for one of these lake houses in or near Shelter Island and enjoy the best of both worlds:

• Get comfortable at "Waterfront Cottage Perfection", where your major priority will be enjoying yourself on, in or around the water. Amenities such as a barbecue grill and beach sun loungers help make this retreat a guest favourite.
• Alternatively, enjoy a more leisurely pace of life at "Montauk House With Lake View". In addition to a refreshing pool, this holiday home offers a nearby beach and a water view.

Curious what the weather's like in Shelter Island? It has an oceanic climate, with average temperatures in summer ranging from 21 ºC to 24 ºC. If you'd love more inspiration on where to stay in this amazing destination, just check out the search bar at the top of the page. Simply adjust the filters to see our full range of Shelter Island holiday homes.

When it comes to lakeside holidays, Shelter Island and its surrounds are home to some amazing spots that promise sun-soaked days and great times galore. Your next epic adventure begins here:

• Lake Ronkonkoma, around 72 kilometres east of the center of Shelter Island, is where treasured holiday memories are created. Dive into some outdoor pursuits or simply soak up the easygoing lake vibes. Book a stay at "Private And Spacious Five Room Suite Steps To Bay Beach And Walk To Village" or "Southold Waterfront Complete With Boat Dock" for ready access to this natural area.
• Fun and sun seekers are drawn to the shoreline of Lake Montauk, around 32 kilometres west of Shelter Island. Love to join them? "The Cooper - Burke House" and "Cozy And Luxurious Sag Harbor Village Home" make terrific bases.

We all need a break every once in a while, and that includes your pooch. Give your four-legged buddy an opportunity to sniff somewhere new and have a blast by the water at one of these pet-friendly lake houses in or near Shelter Island:

• Located around 31 kilometres east of Shelter Island, your fur child can be a part of the holiday fun at "Waterfront Cottage Perfection". As well as being within close proximity to the lake, it comes with optional golf privileges and nearby hunting activities.
• Good boys and girls are also welcome at "Montauk House With Lake View". This lakeside retreat is around 32 kilometres to the east of Shelter Island and offers nearby ecotour services and a nearby beach.

If you've been dreaming about a holiday near the water, swerve the beach and stay at one of these luxury lake houses in Shelter Island instead:

• Appreciate the finer things at "Shelter Island Hidden Waterfront Gem" in Downstate New York. Located near a glittering lake, this lush getaway features golf and a fireplace.
• Spend your waking hours having fun on the lake and your evenings lounging in luxury at "Mid - Island Retreat. Newly Renovated". A firepit and golf are some of the highlights of this Mid-Atlantic holiday house.

You don't have to decide between a getaway in the hills or by the water. These mountain lake houses in or around Shelter Island deliver the best of both beautiful worlds:

• "Waterfront Southold Retreat Steps To Beaches" is around 8 kilometres west of Shelter Island and a popular spot to escape the hustle and bustle. When you're not discovering the nature around you, take advantage of amenities such as a stovetop and free WiFi. As many as 16 guests can stay in the 4 bedrooms here.
• Mountain adventures and rambles around the lake are there for the taking at "Unspoiled North Fork Charm, Walk To Bay And Sound Beaches", around 8 kilometres north of Shelter Island. Invite up to 3 of your best buddies to this retreat which features 2 bedrooms, pet-friendly services and a nearby marina.

Turn an ordinary Friday into a real "Fri-yay!" by clocking off early and going away for the weekend. These lake houses in Shelter Island were made for sneaking in a bit of R&R near the water:

• Stay at "Shelter Island Hidden Waterfront Gem" in Suffolk County and enjoy your days at nature's poolside. Prominent attractions such as Orient Beach State Park and Bay Street Theatre are nearby if you're up for a bit of sightseeing.
• Relaxation or adventure? Whatever you're into, you'll have plenty of both at "Mid - Island Retreat. Newly Renovated" in Mid-Atlantic. Lounge around in your cosy lake house or get out and explore Kontokosta Winery and Sparkling Pointe.

Just you, your nearest and dearest and nature; lake cabin resorts in Shelter Island offer a perfect escape from the busyness of life. Spend precious time with family or friends at these popular getaways:

• Stay in and soak up the quiet atmosphere at "Shelter Island Hidden Waterfront Gem" or spend your days lakeside. Amenities at this Suffolk County home include a barbecue grill and a microwave oven.
• Another top place for a fun waterside escape is "Mid - Island Retreat. Newly Renovated" in Mid-Atlantic. It offers a TV, a nearby marina and more.