Photo by Evgeniy Kolesnikov

Fire Island lake rentals

We found 11 lake rentals — enter your dates for availability

  • Peace of mind

    Our Book with Confidence guarantee gives you 24/7 support
  • More quality time

    From booking to staying, the whole process is simple and enjoyable
  • All the privacy of home

    Enjoy full kitchens, laundry, pools, gardens and more
  • More for less

    More space, more privacy, more amenities — more value

Frequently asked questions

Can I find lakefront holiday homes in Fire Island?
Get ready for calming scenery and tons of fun both on and off the water. Whether you're after an intimate cabin retreat or a big house to hang out with your fam, there's a lakefront holiday home in Fire Island that'll float your boat (or paddleboard):

  • Spend your break at "Great Location - - Newly Renovated" in Lutsen. After a day of trying some activities like surfing and boogie boarding and sailing, you'll love coming home to this retreat's comforts and lovely scenery.
  • Throw yourself into the lakeside lifestyle at "Fabulous Fire Island Beach House" in Seaview. Surfing and boogie boarding, fishing or simply doing nothing are all perfectly good ways to spend a stay here.

Are there any lake house holiday homes with a private pool in Fire Island?
There's no shortage of lake house holiday homes with private pools in Fire Island. Whether you want to spend your escape frolicking by the lake or relaxing in the privacy of your own home, the choice is all yours at these getaways:

  • Say hello to "Waterfront Cottage Perfection", where the first item on your agenda should be relaxing poolside or lakeside. It's located in Town of East Hampton and comes with handy amenities, including games and a restaurant dining guide.
  • Enjoy a refreshing dip in your own pool and then roam around the lake at "Montauk House With Lake View". Located in Town of East Hampton, a barbecue grill and off-street parking options will help make your visit even more enjoyable.

How can I find the best waterfront cabin holiday homes in Fire Island?
Easy. With our handy filter function you can search for holiday properties by location, price and more. And if you're worried about plans changing right at the last moment, don't sweat it; there are also places that provide free cancellation. With Bookabach, the best waterfront cabin holiday homes are just a couple of clicks away.
Are there pet-friendly lake house holiday homes in Fire Island?
If there's no way you'd contemplate taking a holiday without your four-legged friend, take a look at these pet-friendly lake houses in Fire Island:

  • Earning top dog status is "Affordable Ocean Beach, Fire Island Studio Max". As well as lovely lake surroundings, this Mid-Atlantic retreat comes with handy amenities such as towels and WiFi.
  • Another place where you can go on walkies by the lake together is "360 Degree Ocean And Bay Views Weekly Summer Holiday homes Sunday To Sunday". This Les Mayons holiday house offers nearby birdwatching activities and towels.

Are there any luxury lake holiday houses in Fire Island?
If you've been dreaming about a holiday by the water, forget about the beach and head to one of these luxury lake houses in Fire Island instead:

  • Boasting bags of style and space for your group, "Great Location - - Newly Renovated" in Lutsen is popular for a good reason. Enjoy perks such as a beach view and a fireplace along with the nature around you.
  • Come for the breathtaking lakeside setting, stick around for the sheer luxury of "Gite In The Alps Of Haute Provence For 2 Pers". This holiday home home in Seaview comes with a nearby beach, a garden and more.

How can I find cheap lake house holiday homes in Fire Island?
To locate cheap lake house holiday homes in Fire Island, you just have to enter your travel details and then click the search button. You can use the page filters to narrow your search by price, property type and more. It's that straightforward. Like more flexibility? Choose a place with free cancellation for extra peace of mind. Plus, our Book with Confidence Guarantee means Bookabach is here for you before, during and after your stay.
Are there any mountain lake holiday houses in Fire Island?
Wake up in the mornings to the sounds of wildlife and enjoy picturesque lake and mountain views. If you'd love to be on the doorstep of one of Mother Nature's best playgrounds, take a look at these mountain lake holiday houses in Fire Island:

  • "Fabulous Fire Island Beach House": This escape in Seaview has 6 bedrooms and amenities including a boat and a kitchen. Once you've settled in, take some pictures of the impressive scenery around you.
  • "Spacious Duplex With Ocean Views And Hot Tub": Perfect for a family break, this Fellering holiday house has 4 bedrooms. When you're not playing near the water or in the mountains, take advantage of children's games and an iron and ironing board.

What are some of the best lake houses to rent for a weekend in Fire Island?
A change of scenery can work miracles, even if it's only for a day or two. Take off to one of these lake houses for a weekend where you can chill or get into adventure mode:

  • Treat your entire crew to a quick stay at "Great Location - - Newly Renovated" in Lutsen. You'll be close to nature and some top attractions, such as 89 North Music Venue and Patchogue Theatre for the Performing Arts.
  • Enjoy lakeside strolls or drop a line in at "Fabulous Fire Island Beach House" in Seaview. When you're ready for an adventure of a different sort, Fire Island Lighthouse and Robert Moses State Park are close by.