Photo by Erisa Dilo

Shelter Island Heights lake rentals

We found 6 lake rentals — enter your dates for availability

  • Peace of mind

    Our Book with Confidence guarantee gives you 24/7 support
  • More quality time

    From booking to staying, the whole process is simple and enjoyable
  • All the privacy of home

    Enjoy full kitchens, laundry, pools, gardens and more
  • More for less

    More space, more privacy, more amenities — more value

Frequently asked questions

Can I find lakefront holiday homes in or near Shelter Island Heights?
Whether you want a lakefront holiday home for a break with your buddies or a family adventure, Bookabach can help. Lock in one of these retreats in or near Shelter Island Heights water lapping the shore:

  • "Waterfront Cottage Perfection" is the perfect combination of outdoorsy fun and homely comforts. Take advantage of handy amenities here such as outdoor furniture and optional golf privileges.
  • Ready access to the water and the comforts of home make "Montauk House With Lake View" hard to top. This appealing lakeside option features air conditioning, a barbecue grill and more.

Are there any lake house holiday homes with a private pool in or near Shelter Island Heights?
Add some extra pizazz to your lakeside holiday by picking somewhere with a private pool. These properties in or near Shelter Island Heights have a swimming space to call your own, together with easy access to beautiful lakes:

  • Pack your swim gear and take your gang to "Waterfront Cottage Perfection". This escape also has loads of other top-notch amenities, such as a stovetop and high-speed internet services.
  • Alternatively, put your bags down and your feet up at "Montauk House With Lake View". Along with an invigorating pool, this holiday home offers an ocean view and nearby museums.

Not sure what the weather is like in Shelter Island Heights? It has an oceanic climate, with average temperatures in summer varying from 21 ºC to 24 ºC. If you're searching for more inspiration on places to stay in this awesome destination, simply use the search bar at the top of the page. Simply adjust the filters to explore our full range of Shelter Island Heights holiday homes.
How can I find the best waterfront cabin holiday homes in or near Shelter Island Heights?
It's simple. With our handy filter you can search for properties by type, price, location, amenities and more. And if you're worried about plans changing at the last moment, it's not a problem; you can also look for places that offer free cancellation. With Bookabach, the best waterfront cabin holiday homes are just a few keystrokes away.
What are the best lakes for holidaying in or near Shelter Island Heights?
Switch things up from the standard beach escape and head for one of these heavenly lakes around Shelter Island Heights instead:

  • You'll never be at a loss for things to do at Lake Ronkonkoma, located around 72 kilometres northeast of the heart of Shelter Island Heights. Unpack your bags at "Private And Spacious Five Room Suite Steps To Bay Beach And Walk To Village" or "Southold Waterfront Complete With Boat Dock" to be near the lake and its leisure activities.
  • Lake Montauk is another favorite. It's about 32 kilometres west of Shelter Island Heights and has plenty of homes on its doorstep. Reconnect with friends or relatives at "The Cooper - Burke House". Alternatively, enjoy the lakeside lifestyle from "Cozy And Luxurious Sag Harbor Village Home".

Are there pet-friendly lake house holiday homes in or near Shelter Island Heights?
Play a game of fetch, go for a walk or just chill near the water together. Whatever you and your faithful friend want to do on your lakeside adventure, one of these pet-friendly lake houses in or near Shelter Island Heights will make the ideal base:

  • Around 32 kilometres east of Shelter Island Heights, your fur baby will be in doggy heaven at "Waterfront Cottage Perfection". In addition to being nice and close to the lake, it features optional golf privileges and a fireplace.
  • All good hounds are also welcome at "Montauk House With Lake View". This lakeside holiday home is roughly 40 kilometres to the east of Shelter Island Heights and features coffee and tea making facilities and free toiletries.

Are there any luxury lake holiday houses in or near Shelter Island Heights?
Spend your waking hours enjoying leisurely walks by the water and your nights relaxing at a luxury lake house in or near Shelter Island Heights. These retreats come with delightful lakeside surroundings and style to boot:

  • Indulge in the finer things at "Waterfront Cottage Perfection". Roughly 32 kilometres to the east of Shelter Island Heights, it offers high-end amenities such as beauty services and golf.
  • Head out on the water or simply relax and take advantage of all the creature comforts of "Montauk House With Lake View". Featuring beauty services and golf, you'll find it around 40 kilometres to the east of Shelter Island Heights.

How can I find cheap lake house holiday homes in or near Shelter Island Heights?
It's a snap. Just enter your travel details, then use our filter function to narrow your results by price. You can customize your search by room count, property type, pet-friendly stays and more. With our Book with Confidence Guarantee, and our all-round wonderful prices, your lakeside escape doesn't need to cost a bundle.
Are there any mountain lake holiday houses in or near Shelter Island Heights?
If a getaway full of outdoor adventure and fresh air sounds dreamy, you'll like our mountain lake houses in or around Shelter Island Heights. Bring the entire family along to these stays, and maybe your fishing rod and hiking boots:

  • Make yourself comfortable for a while at "Waterfront Southold Retreat Steps To Beaches". This leading holiday home is around 6 kilometres southwest of Shelter Island Heights and features 4 bedrooms with enough room for 16 guests. Heating and nearby museums will make your stay here even more comfortable.
  • Whether you'd love to meander around the lake or trek through the mountains, "Unspoiled North Fork Charm, Walk To Bay And Sound Beaches" delivers plenty of opportunity for adventure. It's around 6 kilometres north of Shelter Island Heights and its 2 bedrooms can accommodate up to 3 of your besties. It's packed with features to keep everyone happy, including a dishwasher and a washing machine.

What are some of the best lake houses to rent for a weekend in or near Shelter Island Heights?
Turn your Friday into a real "Fri-yay!" by clocking out early and getting away for the weekend. These lake houses in Shelter Island Heights are ideal for sneaking in some R&R near the water:

  • "Resort Style Family Beach House With Pool" in Shelter Island Heights proves life is better at the lake. Spend your weekend having fun by the water and exploring close-by attractions, such as Bay Street Theatre and Kontokosta Winery.
  • Wander lakeside or throw a line in at "Waterfront Victorian Farmhouse With Heated Pool And Deepwater Dock" in Shelter Island Heights. When you're ready for an adventure of a different type, Sparkling Pointe and Raphael Winery are close by.

Are there any lake cabin resorts in or near Shelter Island Heights?
When you want to be nestled in nature but have the comforts of home, a lake cabin resort is the way to go. Give the little ones some thrilling outdoor experiences or enjoy a romantic getaway with your honey at these Shelter Island Heights retreats:

  • Stay in and make the most of the peace and tranquility at "Resort Style Family Beach House With Pool" or have fun by the lake. Amenities at this Shelter Island Heights property include air conditioning and heating.
  • "Waterfront Victorian Farmhouse With Heated Pool And Deepwater Dock" is another option where you can leave it all behind and connect with Mother Nature. Located in Shelter Island Heights, pet-friendly services and free toiletries are some of the conveniences here.