Fire Island Pines lake rentals

We found 5 lake rentals — enter your dates for availability

Find spaces that suit your style

  • Peace of mind

    Our Book with Confidence guarantee gives you 24/7 support

  • More quality time

    From booking to staying, the whole process is simple and enjoyable

  • All the privacy of home

    Enjoy full kitchens, laundry, pools, gardens and more

  • More for less

    More space, more privacy, more amenities — more value

Frequently asked questions

Can I find lakefront holiday homes in or near Fire Island Pines?
We've got a wide range of lakefront holiday homes in or near Fire Island Pines where you can chill out by the peaceful, glassy water. Here are some top picks:

  • "Great Location - - Newly Renovated" is the perfect mix of outdoor excitement and creature comforts. Make the most of amenities here including WiFi and a living room.
  • After a full day out on the water, wind down at "Fabulous Fire Island Beach House". This popular lakefront property comes with a host of features, including a garden and a nearby bay.

Are there any lake house holiday homes with a private pool in or near Fire Island Pines?
A pool is a fun and easy way to keep your kiddies happy. Settle back with a good book, dip your toes in the water or organise a game of pool volleyball with the crew. Get ready for loads of aquatic excitement at these lake house properties with private pools in or near Fire Island Pines:

  • A pool is not the only thing you can expect at "Great Location - - Newly Renovated". Other handy amenities at this lakeside getaway include a barbecue grill and high-speed internet services.
  • Leave behind the 9-to-5 and make a beeline to "Fabulous Fire Island Beach House". With the wilderness right on your doorstep and conveniences like a nearby bay and high-speed internet services at your fingertips, you're sure to have a restful stay.

How can I find the best waterfront cabin holiday homes in or near Fire Island Pines?
Simply enter your preferred travel dates, then use our filter function to narrow your search by location, price, amenities and more. We understand that flexibility is important, which is why you can also find getaways that allow free cancellation. Whether it's a lakeside manor with room aplenty or a charming spot high in the mountains, we'll help you find the best waterfront cabin holiday home.
Are there pet-friendly lake house holiday homes in or near Fire Island Pines?
We all deserve a break every once in a while, and that includes your pooch. Give your faithful friend the chance to sniff some new smells and have fun by the water at one of these pet-friendly lake houses in or near Fire Island Pines:

  • After an energetic day by the lake, your pup will enjoy curling up at "2 Acre Gated Estate". It comes with amenities including air conditioning and shopping and is roughly 32 kilometres northeast of Fire Island Pines.
  • Or, enjoy a few nights or longer at "Sayville Area - Exquisite Beachhouse", around 8 kilometres to the north of Fire Island Pines. Off-street parking options and an ocean view are a few amenities at this lakeside property.

Are there any luxury lake holiday houses in or near Fire Island Pines?
Spend your days enjoying leisurely walks by the water and your evenings in total comfort at a luxury lake house in or around Fire Island Pines. These holiday homes come with delightful lakeside surroundings and plenty of style:

  • Escape into nature without giving up the tiniest bit of comfort at "Great Location - - Newly Renovated". Approximately 5 kilometres to the east of central Fire Island Pines, this plush property offers a fireplace and a beach view.
  • Venture out on the water or just kick back and make the most of all the creature comforts of "Gite In The Alps Of Haute Provence For 2 Pers". Featuring a separate dining area and a restaurant dining guide, it's located around 6 kilometres to the west of Fire Island Pines.

How can I find cheap lake house holiday homes in or near Fire Island Pines?
It's easy. All you need to do is enter your preferred dates and destination, then use our handy page filter to narrow your results by price. You can also tailor your search by property type, location and more. With our Book with Confidence Guarantee, and our all-round terrific prices, your lakeside escape doesn't need to be expensive.
Are there any mountain lake holiday houses in or near Fire Island Pines?
Only one thing beats a holiday, and that's holidaying someplace with both superb mountains and lakes. These mountain lake houses will help make your next getaway one you'll never forget:

  • "Fabulous Fire Island Beach House" is around 6 kilometres west of Fire Island Pines and a popular spot to escape the routine. When you're not discovering the nature on your doorstep, make use of amenities such as a boat and heating. As many as 11 guests can stay in the 6 bedrooms here.
  • Whether you'd like to run around the lake or hike in the mountains, "2 - Acre Modern Estate In Southampton. 10 Mins To Wineries" promises opportunities galore for adventure. It's around 48 kilometres northeast of Fire Island Pines and its 4 bedrooms can accommodate up to 10 family members. It's filled with features to keep the crew happy, including a microwave oven and towels.

What are some of the best lake houses to rent for a weekend in or near Fire Island Pines?
Lure a fish, go for a wander or just relax and enjoy the view. If you're craving some time in nature, check out these lake houses to rent for a weekend in or near Fire Island Pines:

  • Rugged adventure or relaxing retreat? It's up to you at "Great Location - - Newly Renovated". Hunker down and enjoy your comfy digs or head outside and make the most of the beautiful lakeside area.
  • Another excellent option is "Fabulous Fire Island Beach House". Round up your crew and enjoy a relaxing stay by the water.

Are there any lake cabin resorts in or near Fire Island Pines?
Visualize yourself waking up to a peaceful lake right outside and then spending your day doing some hiking, water sports and fishing. That's what's on the itinerary at these lake cabin resorts in or near Fire Island Pines:

  • Take life slowly or throw yourself into all the great activities "Great Location - - Newly Renovated" has to offer. Around 5 kilometres east of Fire Island Pines, it comes with plenty of amenities including a separate dining area and an iron and ironing board.
  • Alternatively, get away with the family to "Fabulous Fire Island Beach House". It's approximately 6 kilometres west of Fire Island Pines and offers a bicycle and heating.