We had a wonderful stay at the Creamery Cottage. The cottage is spacious, and the kitchen & bathrooms well-appointed. The location is stellar, with "downtown" Pt. Reyes Station less than a 5 minute walk away. If you are into the outdoors, you couldn't pick a better spot for an HQ while you explore the many attractions of Pt. Reyes.
Our only criticism would be the sitting furniture (chairs/couches), which were quaint and classic, but not very comfortable. Aside from the dining room table there wasn't really a great place for us to gather and comfortably sit together as a family.
That said, we had a great time and would return in the future.