Enjoy some quality time with your loved ones when you book this 3-bedroom, 1-bathroom vacation rental in Jamestown. Nestled on the shore of Pymatuning Reservoir, this cottage offers serene water views, a relaxing setting, and unique interior accents, like the cafeteria tabletop paneling in the great room. Take your retreat to the Pennsylvania countryside to the next level by visiting Pymatuning State Park, less than 3 miles away, and the town of Greenville, just 10 miles down the road.
-- THE PROPERTY --
Renovated in 2021 | Washer & Dryer | Free WiFi | Pymatuning Lake Access w/ Lakefront Mooring Space
Bedroom 1: 2 Full Beds | Bedroom 2: Custom-Built Vintage Triple Twin Bunk Bed | Bedroom 3: Custom-Built Vintage Triple Twin Bunk Bed
OUTDOOR LIVING: Tree swing, seasonal dock (mid May-mid October), lakefront views, lawn chairs, expansive yard, gas grill (propane not provided), bonfire pit (wood not provided) INDOOR LIVING: 1 small flat-screen TV, DVD player, dining table, cathedral ceilings, ceiling fans, books, 2 recliners, wood-burning fireplace KITCHEN: Fully equipped w/ stainless steel appliances, drip coffee maker & built in coffee/tea bar, water filter, dishware/flatware, pots/pans, cooking sheets GENERAL: Central heating & air conditioning, linens, shower & beach towels, complimentary toiletries, hair dryer FAQ: 1 step required for access PARKING: Garage (1 vehicle), driveway (2 vehicles)
-- THE LOCATION --
GET OUTSIDE: Pymatuning Lake Reservoir (direct access), Pymatuning State Park (2.5 miles), Snodgrass Boat Ramp (3.2 miles), Pymatuning Deer Park (3.6 miles), State Game Lands 214 (9.2 miles), Shenango Wildlife Area (15.7 miles), Maurice K Goddard State Park (22.3 miles) GREENVILLE: Greenville Railroad Museum Park (9.8 miles), Canal Museum (9.8 miles), Riverside Park (9.8 miles), Pinehill Golf Course (10.7 miles), Serendipity House of Treasures (10.8 miles), Kidd's Mill Covered Bridge (14.0 miles) LOCAL DINING: Mortals Key Brewing Company (0.5 miles), 215 Restaurant (3.3 miles), Jamestown Hunger Buster (3.3 miles), Dutch Oven Family Restaurant (3.4 miles), Bob's Place (3.9 miles), The Bent Fork (10.3 miles) AIRPORT: Pittsburgh International Airport (81.7 miles), Cleveland Hopkins International Airport (83.1 miles)
-- REST EASY WITH US --
Evolve makes it easy to find and book properties you'll never want to leave. You can relax knowing that our properties will always be ready for you and that we'll answer the phone 24/7. Even better, if anything is off about your stay, we'll make it right. You can count on our homes and our people to make you feel welcome — because we know what vacation means to you.
-- POLICIES --
- No smoking - No pets allowed - No events, parties, or large gatherings - No shoes on the carpets - Additional fees and taxes may apply - Photo ID may be required upon check-in - NOTE: Provided toiletries include: 2 rolls of toilet paper per bathroom, 1 roll of paper towels, 2+ laundry pods, 1 hand soap per room, 2+ dishwasher pods, and dish soap. You will need to supply your own if you need additional supplies - NOTE: The property requires 1 up step and may be difficult for guests with limited mobility - NOTE: The private dock and mooring space can be used, but all other docks are private property to neighbors and should not be used. The dock is available seasonally from mid May through mid October
Add dates for prices
Have a question?
AI iconBetaBeta
Get instant answers with AI powered search of property information and reviews.
Grove City Premium Outlets - 46 min drive - 61.0 km
Eastwood Mall - 49 min drive - 73.1 km
Youngstown State University - 54 min drive - 87.0 km
Getting around
Youngstown, OH (YNG-Youngstown - Warren Regional) - 45 min drive
Restaurants
Jamestown VFW - 6 min drive
Mortals Key Brewing Company - 3 min walk
Crystal Lake Inn - 12 min drive
Pumphouse 45 - 11 min drive
Jamestown Fireman's Club - 6 min drive
Frequently asked questions
Is Custom-Built Lakefront Cottage w/ Spacious Yard! pet-friendly?
No, pets are not allowed at this property.
How much does it cost to stay at Custom-Built Lakefront Cottage w/ Spacious Yard!?
As of 15 May 2026, prices found for a 1-night stay for 2 adults at Custom-Built Lakefront Cottage w/ Spacious Yard! on 20 July 2026 start from NZ$776, including taxes and fees. This price is based on the lowest nightly price found in the last 24 hours for stays in the next 30 days. Prices are subject to change. Choose your dates for more accurate prices.
How much is parking at Custom-Built Lakefront Cottage w/ Spacious Yard!?
On-site parking is available at the property.
What time is check-in at Custom-Built Lakefront Cottage w/ Spacious Yard!?
Check-in begins at 4:00 PM.
What time is check-out at Custom-Built Lakefront Cottage w/ Spacious Yard!?
Checkout is at 11:00 AM.
Where is Custom-Built Lakefront Cottage w/ Spacious Yard! located?
Situated on the waterfront, this cottage is within a 15-minute walk of Pymatuning Reservoir and Pymatuning State Park. Pymatuning Marina and Pymatuning Waterfowl Area are also within 9 miles (15 km).
Reviews
9.2
Wonderful
Reviews are presented in chronological order, subject to a moderation process, and verified unless otherwise labelled.
This is a very nice lakefront cottage. The cottage was clean, well stocked, and very comfortable. The dock on the lake was perfect and allowed me to easily come in and out on my boat.
Simply wonderful and so much character. Even though the weather for our trip was drab, the home was so cozy and accommodating that we couldn't help but have a wonderful time.
Perfect for a 5 day fishing trip. Cottage is in great shape with newer appliances and thoughtful touches from the host in case you forget little things. Biggest plus was the dock which we used for our pontoon boat. No need to drive everyday to a launch or marina!
Alex J.
Stayed 5 nights in Jul 2025
From a partner site
8/10 Good
Brian
5 May 2025
Brian
Had a great time, everything was as advertised. Bunkbeds are not comfortable for adults, other than that I would stay there again.
The cabin was equipped wirh everything needed! It was beautiful and filled with character. A great place gor a girls' weekend. We spent time at Lisa's General Store and headed to the quaint shops in Volant We thoroughly enjoyed the brews nearby (half mile from cabin) and dinner at Carini's.
Maria S.
Stayed 2 nights in Oct 2019
From a partner site
10/10 Excellent
Darlene
31 July 2024
Great cottage
We all really enjoyed the cottage. Very well shocked. Thank you so much for sharing your place with us. Love the outside ,water the whole works. We will highly recommend this place to anyone. T
It was the cleanliness and attention to detail that was so impressive with this property! From the upgrades to the kitchen, bathroom, and bedrooms. Quality linens, dishware, towels and amenities!! Top notch! We did not use the bunk beds, but look perfect for kids. The view from the dining table was gorgeous! Don't miss reading the history wall. It is quite an uphill hike to and from the boat dock, but it was new and in perfect condition! We will certainly consider renting it again!Pittsburgh, PA Sept. 17 - 23, 2025
sharon t.
Stayed 6 nights in Sep 2025
Verified
4/10 Poor
Jessica B.
5 November 2018
Quaint Cottage
This cottage is very quaint. It has beautiful views of the lake. There is no access to the lake from the property though due to a steep shoreline. The neighboring house is also quite close. It is an older home with a musty smell and could use some appliance upgrades as well as new bedding and towels. Also, was hoping to find some interesting places to visit in Jamestown area but there's not much to see.
Jessica B.
Stayed 2 nights in Oct 2018
Response from VrboOwner on 22 March 2020
Jessica, we're glad that you enjoyed the beautiful views from this property! However, we're sorry that your stay fell short of your expectations. We thank you for your suggestions and have passed them along to the homeowner for further consideration. While many of the issues you faced are outside of the owner's control, we're sorry they negatively impacted your stay. Thank you for your feedback, and we wish you the best in all your future travels! Best, the Evolve Team
We traveled with a group of ten people ranging in age from 10-70. The cabin is beautiful, cozy, clean, and fully stocked with kitchen items, linens, cleaning supplies and more. It feels much bigger than the pictures show due to the vaulted ceilings in the main living area and views. Gorgeous view of the lake from the inside living and dining area, and a fire pit outside perfect for sharing stories & making s'mores. Good spot for kids to skip rocks, swing, run, and play! Right down the street from a Brewery & Winery, close to all local attractions. Absolutely loved this place! Thank you!
Attentive owners, lovely lakefront, nice kitchen and bathroom. If you are looking for a nice get a way with your kids, this is the perfect place. State park trails, winery and lovely lake scenery makes this a good spot for a family vacation.
I booked this for my birthday retreat with my friends. Property has a beautiful lake view, they should include the picture in their listing. The two major issues was the property manager's response to texts and calls (which was non existent) and the Hot water from all faucets stinks.
What a beautiful little cottage. My wife and I had such a relaxing time whether it was by the fireplace, on the recliners looking out the big beautiful windows at the lake or on one of the zero gravity chairs underneath the big oak tree. What a great place to unwind and enjoy the lake life.
Everything at this location was in perfect order. the beds were very nice and comfortable and it was very quite. The only problem was the smell and taste of the water and it was not that bad. The pluses of this property far outweighed this one single problem. We would stay here again.
We had a really nice weekend at the cabin with my son and husband. The cabin was cozy and the view was AMAZING. It was a nice quiet getaway and just what we needed.
We wanted a place to stay in the area that felt like camping but wasn’t the campground—this was perfect! We had 4 kids under 5 with us and it was the perfect stress-free trip! Close to the dam, the spillway, the brewery and town—would definitely recommend for anyone especially families!
Katie M.
Stayed 2 nights in Jun 2019
Verified
6/10 Okay
joshua m.
27 May 2019
It was ok
The cabin was very nice and so was the location but the internet did not work the whole time we was there. The fridge didnt seem to get cold and the towels and wash clothes were very musty smelling also the fire pit they had was very strange and I personally thought would be hard to cook or even add logs to.
joshua m.
Stayed 2 nights in May 2019
Response from VrboOwner on 22 March 2020
Joshua, we're happy to hear that you enjoyed the cabin and its location! However, we're sorry that some aspects of your stay didn't match up to your expectations. We have relayed your experience to the homeowner, so we can work together to improve future traveler's experience. We apologize for any inconvenience you encountered during your stay. Thank you for making us aware, and we hope to have the chance to host you again soon! Best, the Evolve Team