We loved Carlin Lake and this area, particularly the fishing and the bike paths. The cabin was as pictured and about what we expected for the price, but a few minor updates (newer towels, better knives, decent ventilation) could make a big difference in the quality of the stay. Our check-in was confusing to say the least, because there was no key in the lockbox, the other door was wide open, and it had not been cleaned. Rich had clean sheets sent over and arranged for the cabin to be cleaned the next morning, but from our considerable experience renting vacation places, this should NOT have happened. Also, be aware that although the website says there is a DVD player, it does not work. While these are all relatively minor issues, together they detracted from our experience. We still enjoyed a very fun week up north, thanks to perfect weather for outdoor activities.