Mystery Bay lake rentals

We found 34 lake rentals — enter your dates for availability

Find spaces that suit your style

  • Peace of mind

    Our Book with Confidence guarantee gives you 24/7 support

  • More quality time

    From booking to staying, the whole process is simple and enjoyable

  • All the privacy of home

    Enjoy full kitchens, laundry, pools, gardens and more

  • More for less

    More space, more privacy, more amenities — more value

Frequently asked questions

Are there any lake house holiday homes with a private pool in or near Mystery Bay?
Of all the features a holiday property can offer, a pool promises the most fun. Have a look at these superb lake houses in or near Mystery Bay and spend your days splashing around in your own pool or unwinding by the shoreline:

  • Pack your swimwear and take a break at "Figtree Cottage - Peaceful Rural Holiday". This getaway also has lots of other quality amenities, such as off-street parking options and a playground.
  • Otherwise, unpack your suitcase at "The Valley Farm Stay In The Heart Of The Tilba Village". As well as its inviting pool, this property offers a firepit and free WiFi.

Mystery Bay has an oceanic climate, with average summertime temperatures hovering between 13 ºC and 24 ºC. But there's no need to wait until summer to visit. Check out the search bar at the top of the page and adjust the filters to find the Mystery Bay holiday home that's perfect for you, and plan your holiday for whenever you like.
How can I find the best waterfront cabin holiday homes in or near Mystery Bay?
Just enter your selected travel dates, then use our filter function to fine-tune your search by price, location, amenities and more. We get that flexibility is important, which is why you can also search for properties that offer free cancellation. Whether it's a lakeside mansion with loads of room or a charming stay in the woods, we'll help you discover the best waterfront cabin holiday home.
Are there pet-friendly lake house holiday homes in or near Mystery Bay?
Play with a Frisbee, run around or just kick back by the water together. Whatever you and your best pal want to do on your lakeside adventure, one of these pet-friendly lake houses in or near Mystery Bay will make a perfect base:

  • After an active day by the lake, your pup will love unwinding at "Figtree Cottage - Peaceful Rural Holiday". It comes with amenities including air conditioning and children's games and is about 2 kilometres north of Mystery Bay.
  • "The Valley Farm Stay In The Heart Of The Tilba Village" is another top lakeside retreat that will get your pup's woof of approval. It features a nearby beach and a barbecue grill and is about 3 kilometres to the west of Mystery Bay.

Are there any luxury lake holiday houses in or near Mystery Bay?
Spend your days enjoying leisurely walks by the water and your evenings in total comfort at a luxury lake house in or near Mystery Bay. These properties come with delightful lakeside surroundings and plenty of style:

  • Immerse yourself in nature without giving up the tiniest bit of comfort at "Figtree Cottage - Peaceful Rural Holiday". About 2 kilometres to the north of central Mystery Bay, this plush property comes with golf and a nearby beach.
  • "The Valley Farm Stay In The Heart Of The Tilba Village" is around 3 kilometres west of Mystery Bay and another great pick. Offering premium perks such as a firepit and a fireplace, it'll score you major brownie points with your gang.

How can I find cheap lake house holiday homes in or near Mystery Bay?
To track down cheap lake house holiday homes in Mystery Bay, all you need to do is type in your travel details and then click search. Play around with the page filters to narrow your search by price. It's that easy. Need flexibility? Choose a holiday home with free cancellation for more peace of mind. Also, our Book with Confidence Guarantee means we're here for you before, during and after your stay.
Are there any mountain lake holiday houses in or near Mystery Bay?
You don't need to decide between a holiday along the water or high in the hills. These mountain lake houses in or around Mystery Bay deliver the best of both gorgeous worlds:

  • Settle in at "Spectacular Coastal Views, Close To Beach". This cosy property is around 48 kilometres south of Mystery Bay and features 2 bedrooms that sleep up to 4 guests. Golf and a nearby river will make your trip even more relaxed and comfy.
  • Alternatively, invite up to 4 of your friends or relatives to "Farmstay Overlooking The Brogo River River With Views Of Mt Mumbulla" which has 2 bedrooms, a hair dryer and a balcony. This appealing holiday home is around 40 kilometres southwest of Mystery Bay.

What are some of the best lake houses to rent for a weekend in or near Mystery Bay?
A weekend trip is an ideal way to break your routine without chewing into too many holiday days. When it's time to recharge your batteries, these lake houses in or near Mystery Bay will be what the doctor ordered:

  • You can pack plenty into a handful of days at "Lakefront Retreat - Water Frontage". You can choose to discover a nearby attraction like Pambula Beach, or plan an outing to Pambula Merimbula Golf Club. Of course, lounging around and admiring the lake vistas is a superb way to spend your break here too.
  • "Figtree Cottage - Peaceful Rural Holiday" is another appealing option. Make sure you add Glasshouse Rocks Lookout and Foxglove Spires Garden to your list if you stay here.

Are there any lake cabin resorts in or near Mystery Bay?
If you're searching for the perfect place to go on holiday with loved ones, you'll score brownie points with a lake cabin resort. Make adventure-filled memories together at one of these stays in or near Mystery Bay:

  • "Figtree Cottage - Peaceful Rural Holiday" will take you away from the hustle and bustle. Stunning natural surroundings, a hair dryer and pet-friendly services are all on offer here. It's around 2 kilometres to the north of Mystery Bay.
  • Or, treat the family to outdoor adventure at "The Valley Farm Stay In The Heart Of The Tilba Village". It's approximately 3 kilometres west of Mystery Bay and offers a hair dryer and a porch.