Having been to the Hawaiian islands 7 times, we were ready to explore the path less traveled and we're glad we did. The cottage has a great Hawaiian feel with lots of island style decor, is very well appointed with anything you'd need and the ocean view is fantastic. (There was an temporary orange safety fence visable from the lanai. I think it is around the area where a building was recently removed and they are trying to grow grass now). The areas in the front and back are well manicured, inviting and well lit at night Our favorite spot was the lanai and it's better than the picture shows since the tile floor was installed. Inside is airy and breezy. There is no air conditioning. Yes, it would've been nice but the breezes and fans made it ok. Sleeping was no problem. (Electricity is very expensive in Hawaii and we were outdoors at the warmer times anyway). The beach is really amazing although the water may be a little rough for some swimmers. We did enjoy some fantastic days there - cooler and beach chairs provided! The pool area is great also. There were times where we had it all to ourselves and the ocean views from there were second to none. We especially enjoyed walking the grounds around sunset.
As for the overall resort: yes, there are numerous abandoned buildings and lots of the windows are boarded or are dirty (ocean mist + dust + breezes), there were some visible pieces of heavy equipment (backhoe, skid steer) on site. There is a general store on site, which we were thankful for, that sells basic groceries (no alcohol) and souveniers. During the daytime, we always saw groundskeeping and maintainance so the areas were being kept.
My review is for the cottage itself which is truly a special place, and for my experience with the owner/manager - excellent communication and fast to respond to any concerns. Do your research and if you want to get away from it all and enjoy a peaceful Hawaiian experience, I definitely recommend this cottage.