Fishers Island lake rentals

We found 7 lake rentals — enter your dates for availability

  • Peace of mind

    Our Book with Confidence guarantee gives you 24/7 support
  • More quality time

    From booking to staying, the whole process is simple and enjoyable
  • All the privacy of home

    Enjoy full kitchens, laundry, pools, gardens and more
  • More for less

    More space, more privacy, more amenities — more value

Frequently asked questions

Can I find lakefront holiday homes in or near Fishers Island?
Whether you're searching for a lakefront holiday home for a break with your buddies or a family trip, we've got you covered. Choose one of these retreats in or near Fishers Island water lapping the shore:

  • "Unspoiled North Fork Charm, Walk To Bay And Sound Beaches" is the ideal fusion of outdoor excitement and homely comforts. Make the most of handy amenities here including a balcony and a theme park.
  • Unrivaled access to the water and all the usual comforts make "Gorgeous Lakefront Retreat" a hard act to beat. This lakeside holiday home comes with tennis, a restaurant dining guide and more.

Are there any lake house holiday homes with a private pool in or near Fishers Island?
A pool is often an essential amenity when considering where to stay, particularly if you've got kids in tow. Want to be near the water too? Go for one of these lake houses in or near Fishers Island and you'll get the best of both worlds:

  • Switch to vacay mode at "Unspoiled North Fork Charm, Walk To Bay And Sound Beaches", where your top priority will be having fun on, in or around the water. Amenities such as a nearby marina and a restaurant dining guide help make this getaway a favourite with guests.
  • Or, enjoy a change of scenery at "Gorgeous Lakefront Retreat". In addition to its inviting pool, this lake house offers off-street parking options and a garden.

Not sure what the weather's like in Fishers Island? It has an oceanic climate, with average temperatures in summer varying from 18 ºC to 24 ºC. If you're after a little more inspiration on where to stay in this awesome destination, just check out the search bar at the top of the page. Simply adjust the filters and explore our full range of Fishers Island holiday homes.
How can I find the best waterfront cabin holiday homes in or near Fishers Island?
To locate the best waterfront cabin holiday homes around Fishers Island, type in your travel dates and use the filters to narrow your search by property type, price and more. Make the most of our map to find the ideal spot. Worried about changing plans? No dramas. Use the filter to hunt for cabin holiday homes that let you cancel for free. You shouldn't have any trouble finding a place for you to relax, laugh and connect with your loved ones.
Are there pet-friendly lake house holiday homes in or near Fishers Island?
Benji enjoys nice long walks along the water too, so take him with you on your next lakeside break. These pet-friendly lake houses in or near Fishers Island will welcome both you and your adventure-loving pooch:

  • After a busy day by the lake, your tired pup will love winding down at "Unspoiled North Fork Charm, Walk To Bay And Sound Beaches". It comes with amenities including a nearby zoo and a theme park and is roughly 32 kilometres southwest of Fishers Island.
  • "Greenport Waterfront Cottage With Private Community Beach" is another excellent lakeside stay that will get your hound's howl of approval. It features a free nearby fitness centre and a nearby waterfront and is approximately 32 kilometres to the southwest of Fishers Island.

Are there any luxury lake holiday houses in or near Fishers Island?
Spend your days having a blast around the lake and your evenings resting in comfort at a luxury lake house in or near Fishers Island. These holiday homes provide idyllic lakeside surroundings and style to spare:

  • "Bookabach Property - Hansel and Gretel Trulli" takes an everyday lakeside holiday to a whole new level. Around 32 kilometres southwest of Fishers Island, this posh property comes with amenities such as a fireplace and a swimming pool.
  • Venture out on the water or just lounge and enjoy the home comforts of "Gorgeous Lakefront Retreat". Featuring a garden and a restaurant dining guide, it's located around 32 kilometres to the southwest of Fishers Island.

How can I find cheap lake house holiday homes in or near Fishers Island?
Simple. All you have to do is type in your travels details, then use our filter tool to narrow your options by price. You can customize your search by property type, location and more. With our Book with Confidence Guarantee, and our all-round fantastic prices, your lakeside break doesn't need to cost a fortune.
Are there any mountain lake holiday houses in or near Fishers Island?
There's no need to choose between a holiday along the water or high in the hills. These mountain lake houses in or around Fishers Island deliver the best of both gorgeous worlds:

  • Reconnect with nature at "Unspoiled North Fork Charm, Walk To Bay And Sound Beaches". This superbly located holiday home comes with 2 bedrooms and a range of amenities, such as high-speed internet services and air conditioning. Around 32 kilometres southwest of Fishers Island, it has enough room for 3 guests.
  • Treks through the mountains and lakeside strolls are what you can expect at "Waterfront Southold Retreat Steps To Beaches", around 40 kilometres southwest of Fishers Island. Invite up to 16 of your best buddies to this stay which features 4 bedrooms, a nearby laundromat and towels.

What are some of the best lake houses to rent for a weekend in or near Fishers Island?
Whether you'd rather stroll along the peaceful water or kick into adventure mode, you'll discover a terrific lake house to rent for a weekend on Bookabach. Here are two of our most popular properties in or near Fishers Island:

  • Relaxation or rugged adventure? Find your own holiday mode at "Unspoiled North Fork Charm, Walk To Bay And Sound Beaches". Sleep in and enjoy your comfortable digs or head out and make the most of the beautiful lake.
  • Leave work early on Friday and set your GPS for "Gorgeous Lakefront Retreat". A wonderful lakeside setting, the conveniences of home and plenty of activities nearby make it an awesome weekend escape.

Are there any lake cabin resorts in or near Fishers Island?
If you're on the lookout for the ideal place to go on holiday with the family, you'll get brownie points for choosing a lake cabin resort. Make wonderful new memories together at one of these options in or near Fishers Island:

  • Take life slowly or throw yourself into all the exciting activities "Unspoiled North Fork Charm, Walk To Bay And Sound Beaches" offers. Approximately 32 kilometres southwest of Fishers Island, it comes with loads of amenities including a private pool and coffee and tea making facilities.
  • "Gorgeous Lakefront Retreat" is another place where you can experience the classic lake holiday. A hair dryer and air conditioning are among the conveniences at this popular option, which is around 32 kilometres southwest of Fishers Island.