Escape to Rustic Roots, a spacious 3-bedroom log cabin in Middlebury, Indiana, nestled on 70 peaceful acres in the heart of Northern Indiana's Amish Country. Just minutes from Shipshewana, our whole-house holiday rental is ideal for families, friends, and groups looking for a relaxing getaway—or a comfortable home base for a Notre Dame football weekend or campus visit.
Rustic Roots offers plenty of space to spread out, relax, and spend time together. With two spacious gathering areas plus a cosy, secluded sitting area, everyone can find their favourite spot.
When you stay at Rustic Roots, you'll have the entire cabin to yourselves. The home features three bedrooms, a full kitchen, dining space, and multiple gathering areas designed with families and groups in mind.
Rustic Roots sits on 70 acres of beautiful Northern Indiana countryside, including farmland, woodland, and wetlands. Enjoy the changing scenery throughout the seasons, listen to the sounds of nature, or simply slow down and appreciate the peaceful surroundings.
While outside you can enjoy the large backyard, fire pit, and fully lit sports court. Challenge your family or friends to a game of pickleball or enjoy other outdoor games together. When evening arrives, gather around the fire pit, relax under the stars, and enjoy the peaceful country setting.
Rustic Roots is conveniently located in Middlebury, Indiana, near Shipshewana and the attractions of Northern Indiana's Amish Country. Spend the day exploring Shipshewana's unique shops, restaurants, attractions and local Amish culture. Visit the Shipshewana Flea Market, discover local markets and shops, enjoy the area's restaurants, or take a scenic drive through the surrounding countryside.
Rustic Roots is also a comfortable home base for families and groups visiting campus, attending an event, or coming to town for a Notre Dame football weekend.
Whether you're visiting Shipshewana and Amish Country, attending a Notre Dame football game, visiting the University of Notre Dame, planning a family holiday, or simply looking for a peaceful Northern Indiana getaway, Rustic Roots gives you room to enjoy your time together.
Spend your days exploring, playing pickleball, relaxing on the decks, or enjoying the countryside. Gather around the fire pit in the evening or settle into one of the comfortable gathering spaces and make yourself at home.
Rustic Roots combines the charm of a log cabin with the space, comfort and recreation your group needs for a memorable Northern Indiana getaway.
Come for the destination. Stay for the peaceful setting. Gather together, slow down, and make memories at Rustic Roots.
Please respect the privacy of the neighbors as the cabin has a shared drive.
Important information
You need to know
Property # 3647995vb
Extra-person charges may apply and vary depending on property policy
Government-issued photo identification and a credit card, debit card or cash deposit may be required at check-in for incidental charges
Special requests are subject to availability upon check-in and may incur additional charges; special requests cannot be guaranteed
On-site parties or group events are strictly prohibited
Host has indicated that there is a carbon monoxide detector on the property
Host has indicated that there is a smoke detector on the property
Safety features at this property include a fire extinguisher, a first aid kit and a deadlock
About the area
Middlebury
Located in Middlebury, this cabin is in a rural area. Six Span Plaza and Shipshewana Auction and Flea Market are worth checking out if shopping is on the agenda, while those wishing to experience the area's natural beauty can explore Lieber Nature Preserve and Elkhart Environmental Center. Travelling with kids? Consider Elkhart County Fairgrounds and Deutsch Kase Haus.
How much does it cost to stay at Rustic Roots / Middlebury Log Cabin / Shipshewana / Notre Dame?
As of 22 Nov 2026, prices found for a 1-night stay for 2 adults at Rustic Roots / Middlebury Log Cabin / Shipshewana / Notre Dame on 21 Jan 2027 start from NZ$984, including taxes and fees. This price is based on the lowest nightly price found in the last 24 hours for stays in the next 30 days. Prices are subject to change. Choose your dates for more accurate prices.
How much is parking at Rustic Roots / Middlebury Log Cabin / Shipshewana / Notre Dame?
On-site parking is available at the property.
What time is check-in at Rustic Roots / Middlebury Log Cabin / Shipshewana / Notre Dame?
Check-in begins at 3:00 PM.
What time is check-out at Rustic Roots / Middlebury Log Cabin / Shipshewana / Notre Dame?
Checkout is at 11:00 AM.
Where is Rustic Roots / Middlebury Log Cabin / Shipshewana / Notre Dame located?
Located in a rural location, this family-friendly cabin is within 6 mi (10 km) of Church Park, Elkhart County Fairgrounds, and Dorothy McFarland Park. Dykstra Park and Dock Lake are also within 6 miles (10 km).
Reviews
10
Exceptional
Reviews are presented in chronological order, subject to a moderation process, and verified unless otherwise labelled.
This property is beautiful! We enjoyed coming back to this cabin after a fun day of shopping. Lindsay thought of everything to make this weekend retreat perfect. We look forward to staying here again!
I have rented many homes and i have never stayed at a home that was as well thought out as this home was. The home is way more beautiful in person, the hosts have thought of everything! They go above and beyond to make their guests comfortable. I would highly recommend this place to all my friends. Can’t wait to return!!
Beautiful cabin with everything you need! Kitchen was well stocked, including k-cups and fresh ground coffee. Bathrooms were well stocked and had plenty of towels and wash cloths. Communication was excellent!!Cabin was perfect for our girls trip, which included plenty of space for crafting, room on the 1st floor for all 11 of us to sit around and socialize, as well as a large table for all of us to eat meals together. Enjoyed the beautiful front porch and enjoyed the sounds of. Store, as well as a few sightings of the animals in the area (deer, chipmunks and squirrels).We were close to shopping in Shipshewana, Ligonier and Goshen. Enjoyed many of the fabric stores in the area.Will definitely plan another stay!!
So warm and inviting and clean!! So much to enjoy while there…pickleball, basketball and the fire pit to make s’mores. Wonderful front porch where we enjoyed our breakfast this morning. Great place for a family gathering.
This is got to be the go to place if you’re staying in this area of Indiana. Until you experience it, there’s no words to describe it. It is absolutely perfect. The house is incredible, the accessories are incredible and the host is beyond incredible. A truly wonderful experience.
This cabin was absolutely wonderful! It was so clean and spacious and had everything we needed. I would highly recommend this property. I just wish we had more time there. We will definitely be back next year!!
We had an awesome weekend. The cabin and grounds were beauitful. Alot of thought was put into having everything we needed for our stay. If ever in the area again will definitely reserve the cabin again!
This place offered way more than expected.. All we did when entering was walk from room to room saying WOW.. Every room had everything that anyone could ever need.... What a pleasure to relax in this atmosphere. 10 ladies and not one complaint.
Our family loved staying in this gorgeous cabin while visiting for a wedding nearby. We could tell that a lot of thought and care has been put into creating a space for families to gather and create memories together. We’re already planning our next trip!
We had a great experience! The cabin was cozy and clean. It was very organized and charming. It was very apparent there was a lot of thought put into the amenities. Everything we could need was provided. Highly recommend!
A first-class property with every amenity you could need. It's a real cabin but feels like a 5-star hotel. Hosts were incredible and communications were answered in seconds. The nighttime pickleball match was something our family will remember forever!
what a beautiful site! The cabin is very spacious and accommodated our large party of 12 very easily. The furnishings and craftsmanship were amazing. Best of all, we were all able to gather in basement area and at the huge table for all meals.
We had the perfect wedding weekend surrounded by family. This cabin was perfect and so incredibly accommodating! All my family was in awe of the beauty of this cabin, thank you for sharing it!
The guys in our son’s wedding party throughly enjoyed their stay at the cabin. The blend of rustic and luxury was perfect for the occasion. I was surprised how many of them came up and specifically thanked us for booking “that amazing cabin” for them. The host was so easy to communicate with and accommodating. Highly recommend!
Stayed 1 night in May 2025
Response from VrboOwner on 4 Jun 2025
Thanks Wendy! I'm glad they all enjoyed themselves :)
About the host
Hosted by Lindsay Williams
I grew up locally in Middlebury on a dairy farm not far from Rustic Roots. I enjoy meeting new people, being a mum and designing and creating art of all kinds.
I co-host this property with my parents, who you may encounter during your stay. It has been a fun adventure for us to begin this hosting journey together.
Why they chose this property
Rustic Roots is located on a 70 acre property that includes farmland, woodlands and wetlands that are all protected by a conservation easement with the Wood Land Lakes Land Trust. Sitting out on the porch and enjoying the beautiful scenery is one of my favourite places to relax and unwind.
What makes this property unique
The cabin is a treasured family home. It was built by my grandparents for the express purpose of entertaining family and friends. People all over the world have enjoyed its welcoming atmosphere, but it's significance is particularly meaningful to our extended family as it has been our go-to gathering place for over 30 years. We hope that everyone who visits the cabin will feel the invitation to rest, relax and enjoy their time here.
Please note, one of our host couples lives in a separate house on the property. The two houses share a driveway, so it is not uncommon to bump into the "neighbour" during your stay. If you see them around, they will likely wave and say hello. If you want to chat, they will be happy to accommodate. However, they are also happy to give you complete privacy if that is your desire.
Languages:
English
Premier Host
They consistently provide great experiences for their guests