I stayed a Manitou a couple of years ago in the cabin...that was a lovely experience. This time, I came with an out- of- town friend and stayed in the main building. Let me say first that both of us are cat lovers and have several (indoor) pet cats, so this isn't an anti-cat statement.
The first thing we both smelled as we entered and throughout the lodge was cat....and not cat urine, but cat spray. The only place away from the smell was in the room. I realize your kitties are outdoor cats.....however, for their health (and one is particular looked very poorly this time), and the comfort of your guests, you may want to invest in having them fixed or kept out of the lodge(but I love the idea of having cats visit). Again, we both love your cats.
Another consideration might be to have brighter lighting in the main lodge. I was there when another pair who were working on a puzzle (until one couldn't take the smell) and they both commented that it would be more comfortable if the lighting was brighter. I know the style bulbs you use give a nice ambiance, but a higher wattage would be nice.
Anyway, I look forward to returning in the future!
Sincerely,
Theresa Calip